It happened fast, as upending revelations do. I was home from the dorms on a Saturday eleven years ago. As my sack of laundry tumbled to softness for another week’s wear, I thumbed through stacks of photos on the dining room table. My mom was in the process of sorting them into two piles, one for her and one for my dad. Their divorce was in its endgame–the two of them weary from battle, but entrenched in it still.
The late morning light filtered through the windows the color of iced tea. I picked up a stack of school photos of goofy looking cousins on my dad’s side, all of them in varying stages of kidness, a missing tooth here, a cowlick there. All of them with twinkles in their eyes, all of them with dimples, marks of another tribe. I flipped through them quickly, like trading cards, unaware that the question I was about to ask my mom in the nonchalant spirit of passing time would change everything.
“Why do all the other grandkids look like grandma while I don’t?”
Even my brother Luke had that playful glint, unlike me, my teatime eyes telling old soul tales from the stack. In that instant, my mom hesitated. Anyone else might not have noticed.
“Mom, why do all the other grandkids look like grandma?”
She fell into a chair, startled, stunned, caught, her dust rag suddenly moot. To this day, I don’t understand how the next question came to me so clearly.
“Mom — is dad my real dad?”
In the minutes that followed I learned that my dad is not my biological father. I learned that they had wanted to tell me the truth so many times, but that my dad was petrified that the truth would strip him of his fatherhood, that I wouldn’t love him anymore. I learned that a close friend of my mom’s, a man I’d known my entire life, is likely my biodad. I left the apartment, my laundry tumbling in the basement, and drove.
Eleven years later, my dad and I are strangers, not because of the paternity issue, but for other reasons. I haven’t seen him in more than five years, but I think about him everyday. I’m weary from managing the emotions he stirs in me–confusion, anger, sadness, loss, abandonment, disappointment. My brother and I talk about him only rarely. When we do, we are comrades from a distant war, braced against the railing of ghosts, fused by the story only the two of us know in common.
I write this now because a month ago the novella of my true paternity rubbed the sleepers from its eyes and stumbled into the adjacent room of my tidy, well-lit life. The man who might be my biological father (known more succinctly as PBD, or Possible Biodad) called my mom at work. He told her that he’d found a shoebox full of pictures and cards I’d colored for him when I was little, that he’d tried to find me through the phone book, that he wants to know me.
She reported this to me over dinner one night with the consternation of a disaster correspondent and, as I absorbed every last syllable, my heart detonated balloons of questions, raining confetti over the landscape of everything I am.
In the weeks since PBD’s expressed interest, my mom has acted dutifully as the go-between– on her one side, a man just past 60, eager and ready to step into a role long denied, and on her other side, a woman just past 30 harboring a broken heart from the only dad she ever knew, but curious to know more intimately the source of her propensities toward rumination and sarcasm, as well as her other numerous idiosyncrasies.
Back and forth my mom facilitated the beginnings of a reunion, never disowning her role in this novella’s genesis, unfaltering in her loyalty to the child in all this, me, and my wish to know for certain, once and for all, that I am linked by double helix to PBD.
Eleven years in the making and the moment of my reconception occurred last week, via four oversized Q-tips. A woman named Cindy (who with her tapered, stonewashed jeans, spearmint gum, and feathery hair, gave me the idea that her boyfriend is a tattooed biker guy who happens also to read Nietzsche) concentrated as she rotated each of the four swabs on the fleshy insides of my cheeks. She sealed the samples in an envelope, took a surprisingly good Polaroid of me, and told me to expect results in five business days. (PBD had been told the same upon his swabbing the previous day.)
My mom would say that she’s been sure of my true parentage for 30 years. However, somewhere in the blur of my 20s I was told that there was another contender, so I haven’t felt as sure. There were nights when I would get out the one picture I have of PBD and hold it next to the one picture I have of Contender #2. I would stare into their still-life eyes, probing for clues, wondering about every little thing any girl in normal circumstances takes for granted about her father. How does he take his coffee? Does he cry? How does he look in a suit? English or math? Dylan or Sondheim? What would he say to me over plates of spaghetti? Would he know me from a stranger?
The past week has been hard. I decided, though, that I want it to be PBD because he is already a 3-dimensional character in my life. I have memories of him in our driveway, wearing mirrored sunglasses. I remember him taking me for a ride on his motorcycle, hugging the exit loop off Hwy 12 with such care. I remember his unexpected collection of turtle figurines when my mom and I dropped by his house one time, BJ Thomas’ Raindrops Keep Falling On My Head playing on the stereo as they talked in the kitchen. Contender #2 is just a pixel, 2-dimensional in a curled photograph, eternally (and unfortunately) clothed in a late 1970s prom tuxedo complete with ruffled shirt.
Cindy said five business days.
Jenn consoled me when, on the fifth business day, the results did not come. My mom and brother checked on me, too. On the seventh day, yesterday, I called Cindy. I told her about my last few anxious trips to the mailbox. She apologized and explained that the results had been faxed to their office yesterday, that she couldn’t give them to me over the phone, but that I could pick them up in person or she would be happy to fax them to me. Given that I don’t own a fax machine or a team of huskies to pull my equally hypothetical sled, I felt landlocked, my stomach pulping itself as I sat on the arm of our overstuffed chair, so close to knowing the truth. Thanks to Google and Jenn’s calm coaching, I learned that the local pharmacy accepts faxes on behalf of customers. I called Cindy back and, within minutes, was at the pharmacy, waiting for the incoming beep of my paternity.
All week I’ve felt conflicted about writing this story here, so publicly. I contemplated that which separates the sacred from the inconsequential. I considered my audience, the diverse range of you, and wondered if this is too personal, how you might feel to be trusted with the gravity of my experience as it’s happening. I weighed whether I could accept it if, once out there, my story garnered little to no reaction at all. In the end, I chose to write it for me. Words pull me together.
The pharmacy tech let me have the fax at no charge, an act of sympathy, perhaps.
This is it, I thought. I fumbled the corner of the cover sheet not unlike a boy undoing a bra. The pages separated. I ransacked the report for the conclusion, the finite bottom line that would either cradle or crumble me in an instant.
Allele size. Locus. Paternity Index. Alleged.
At last, I found the number I needed to find.
I beamed, exorcised of doubt, light as air, and hastened outside where Jenn waited in our silently idling hybrid. I showed her the page and we drove home.
Thirty years in the making, the truth is mine.






27 Comments
March 23, 2008 at 2:12 pm
My god. I am (for once) speechless. I can’t imagine what you’ve been going through.
Thank you for putting this out there, Erika. Thank you for being brave in so many ways. I am in awe of you.
March 23, 2008 at 5:58 pm
My God you wrote this yesterday – YESTERDAY – and here I am, wandering through my ridiculously self-absorbed life, no idea that this bomb was sitting here. Not only is this a stunning turn of events, but the writing – MY GOD, GIRL. Jesus H. And I say all this on Easter of all days!
You need to drop everything and write a book.
I’m sorry I didn’t read this yesterday. 18 hours in the car. Then today, fumbling through the morning, catching up on stupid shit.
God I wish I knew what to say. I’m just gonna stop talking now. I’m just….
I guess like Pare said, I’m in awe. Awe is a damn good word for it.
March 23, 2008 at 10:30 pm
My God, Erika. First of all, beautifully written – I have goose bumps.
Like Maggie, I’ve been living such a self-centered life lately, and then I see this and immediately made myself stop.
Thank you for taking a huge chance and sharing this. I wish I could think of something better to say than that, but there you go.
March 24, 2008 at 2:34 pm
Beautiful and amazing! How are you? How is everything?
We should talk sometime…I don’t have this one, but, I would love to offer up support.
March 24, 2008 at 2:46 pm
I came via Maggie. I’m glad it was PBD for you. This is impressive, in both the writing and the putting it out there. Thanks.
March 24, 2008 at 3:00 pm
Came over via Maggie.
MY GOSH, this was powerful. Also, are you my half-sister?
I have a half-sister out there that could very well have written most of that. My dad is trying to reconnect with her (though she’s known for most of her life that my dad is likely her dad, too) and she is unsure if she wants to do the DNA test. Thank you for putting your story out there, I think she might benefit from this.
March 24, 2008 at 3:49 pm
I seriously heart you to pieces. You are an absolutely amazing writer, Erika. And the fact that you can share this with us, the collective readers, is a feat in itself.
I’m glad you found peace. I’m going to quit stressing about my nail-biting habits now.
Thanks for the perspective.
March 24, 2008 at 4:07 pm
I have to thank Maggie for sending me your way because this resonates with me in a way that I’m not capable of sharing. I’m bowled over by your writing. And bravery. Thanks.
March 24, 2008 at 5:20 pm
Damn Erika. What an incredible post.
(I’ve been sitting here, staring at this blank comment box for about 10 minutes now and I can’t think of anything else to say. You’ve left me speechless. Hard to believe, I know, but it’s true.)
How are you? I hope that you are able to find peace in all of this. Please know that I’m thinking of you.
March 24, 2008 at 6:03 pm
(made the bounce from Maggie)
goodness, but you have been through a lot. i hope that however things go from here, you are well.
March 24, 2008 at 7:06 pm
I cam over via Maggie also.
This is so phenomenal. Not only is my heart all over the place, but your writing is gorgeous.
March 24, 2008 at 8:16 pm
I, too came over via Maggie.
Thank you, Maggie for the link. And thank you, Erika for sharing such a beautiful and enormously well-written story.
I have to agree with everyone else here. It does put my trivial stresses in perspective.
And it makes me want to hug my dad. (Who also rides a Harley)
You are wonderful!
March 24, 2008 at 9:28 pm
I am not quite sure how I found your blog but I am glad I did.
I work for a DNA lab called Identigene. Your story really reminds me of the human side of what we do. Hopefully making DNA testing available and inexpensive will help others in your type of situation. Thank you for sharing. You must be a very strong person!
March 25, 2008 at 2:15 am
Erika,
I am constantly amazed by your posts, both by how candid you are with us in relaying these experiences, but also in the unbelievably talented way you share them.
I am glad you were able to finally get the answer you have been seeking. Thank you for sharing! -Andi
March 25, 2008 at 2:44 am
Another here because of Maggie, stayed because of you. And your writing. Beautiful and searing. So many have such unresolved issues, unrealized hopes and unuttered wishes. I am glad you have the truth that is so rightfully yours.
March 25, 2008 at 5:18 am
Maggie, you know how to pick ‘em.
Erika,
This stood out to me . . .
“I contemplated that which separates the sacred from the inconsequential. I considered my audience, the diverse range of you, and wondered if this is too personal, how you might feel to be trusted with the gravity of my experience as it’s happening. I weighed whether I could accept it if, once out there, my story garnered little to no reaction at all. In the end, I chose to write it for me. Words pull me together.”
This is where I’m at right now. I just began blogging about three weeks ago, a “living memoir” that’s me – then and up-to-the-minute. It’s right to tremble when you let it all hang out here in blogland, for it’s doing so many things right.
You have a gift – nurture it.
Brian
March 25, 2008 at 3:49 pm
This was an incredible piece of your life that you shared- Thank you! I came in and read this last night, but couldn’t think of anything profound to say, comparative to your beautifully told story.
Wow. Just wow.
March 26, 2008 at 1:30 am
Erika -
Wow! This must have been weighing on your mind for a long time. I’m glad you were able to find the truth. You are a wonderful woman – the PBD provided outstanding DNA. Say “hi” to your mom, Dan, and Luke. We were so warmly welcomed into their home at the rehearsal dinner. You are blessed to have that kind of family.
March 26, 2008 at 5:41 am
Hi, Erika–
I came over after a tip from Maggie, and I’m so glad I did. What an incredible story. So impressive that you’ve shared this … and shared it so eloquently. I wish you luck following whatever path you choose with PBD.
March 26, 2008 at 12:34 pm
Maggie again!
I can’t begin to imagine your journey but do have a minor connection on this. My eldest stepson is not my husband’s biological son and does not know his BD (although there is a PBD…he went back to the UK 21 years ago and has not been heard of since).
The havoc which has been wrought upon this young man’s life as a result of his careless parents is miserable to behold. I sincerely hope your journey is gentler and that this new discovery enables you to explore ‘you’ and create a secure place for yourself in the world.
Oh…and what they said about your writing too….
March 26, 2008 at 5:20 pm
Wow, what an amazing story. I’m glad you shared it! My “dad” is not my biological father – I learned it at a fairly early age, but can’t quite recall.
My biodad has never been in my life. He was cheating with some neighbor girl when my mom was pregnant with me, and they divorced right around when I was born. Mom says he met me once right after she’d given birth, and that was about it.
I know his name, and thanks to a well-meaning relative, have seen a picture (I have his eyes!). Sometimes I’d like to know him, but other times I say “to hell with you, cheater asshole.”
Mainly, I’d like to know what my heritage is on his side, and to know if I should watch out for anything like history of certain illnesses or crazytimes or anything.
Oh, and while she hasn’t been in contact with him since the divorce, my mom did see him on Jeopardy once in the mid 80s. He didn’t win.
March 26, 2008 at 5:21 pm
Oh, and also – you’re a fantastic writer. I always enjoy your blog posts!
March 26, 2008 at 11:59 pm
Wow…family secrets. I’m so glad for you that you know the truth.
March 28, 2008 at 2:44 am
I want to say so much…I am so happy for you and as I write this I feel tears start to well up in my eyes.s I would rather hug you tight and tell you that I love you very much. I am sure I will be able to do that soon, but for now I will simply say….nope I got nothing.
Actually I will say this. It is because of reading experiences like this, you (and others) have made me feel comfortable sharing my thoughts. Thank you so very much.
I know you have 7 layers of people around you, but just so you know…8 is right here.
March 30, 2008 at 8:04 pm
Wow. Just…beautiful and poignant.
Thank you for sharing this journey.
April 1, 2008 at 11:28 pm
Very moving story and so well told. I ‘m sure you could get this published if you wanted to. I love your ending sentence, implying that the truth is even more important than results and that the truth is what sets us free.
April 2, 2008 at 2:48 pm
I just found your blog through a comment on Nutmeg’s blog. Likin’ it – you’re a talented writer. This post is so well written I was captivated throughout.
I’m glad you got the results you were hoping for.
Count me as a new subscriber to your feed.